[78-L] Malcolm Sargent - Messiah

David Lennick dlennick at sympatico.ca
Mon Mar 11 13:37:18 PDT 2013


Disc numbers for US Columbia 78s:
71891/71909D in M 666, per WERM which always opted to list the manual version 
unless there was no choice. Columbia's 1949 catalog shows MM 666 but no disc 
numbers (71910/71928D would be my guess).
English Columbia set number is 313, no prefix (per 1948-9 catalogue). Manual 
sequence DX 1283/1301, auto sequence DX 8223/8241.

On 3/11/2013 4:29 PM, David Lennick wrote:
> SL 51 might be manual and SL 151 auto sequence. I have it on 78s, with
> slipcase, and it's master pressings (and it occasionally turns up on eBay with
> a million dollar price tag..per volume).
>
> 666..funny, from a company that abandoned a 13000 series because of
> superstitious customers 20 years earlier.
>
> dl
>
> On 3/11/2013 4:27 PM, Thomas Stern wrote:
>>     Questions about the 1946 Malcolm Sargent recording of MESSIAH - this is the version with Isobel Baillie, Gladys Ripley,
>> James Johnston, Norman Walker, the Huddersfield Choral Society, and the Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra.
>>
>>     According to the DUTTON reissue (2CDEA 5010) this was recorded Huddersfield Town Hall, 12-17 July, 26 September 1946.
>>
>> Columbia(UK) DX 1283-1301 (CAX 9572-9609)  19 disks    IS THERE A SET NUMBER?
>> Columbia(US) Set 666  19 disks, in 2 volumes.          WHAT ARE THE Disk numbers?
>>     Is the US version dubbed ?
>>
>> The US Columbia set appears to have been reissued on LP in set SL-51 or SL-151 (3-LPs).  There appear
>> to be 2 versions - a slipcased set, with 3 LP's in individual jackets, notes and texts on the jackets,
>> and also a conventional BOX containing 3 LP's and libretto.
>>
>> Can someone enlighten me on the catalog numbering scheme of the SL-51 issue ?
>> When was the Slipcase packaging used?  when was it replaced by a conventional Box?  or were they same era???
>> Slipcase appears to indicate set SL-51, 1st disk is SL-51, disk 2 and 3 SL-151, also numbered ML-4110, 4111, 4112).
>> Box issue appears to be set SL-151.
>>
>> Any other variants?
>>
>> Was this set issued on LP in the UK ?
>> Was this set issued on CD in the UK or US (other than DUTTON) ?
>>
>> Thanks!
>> Best wishes, Thomas.
>>


More information about the 78-L mailing list