[78-L] Eureka! I mean, Eroica!

[David Lennick]

Maybe they thought it was more up to date..it was still in the catalogue in 
1934, while the Wood (M-46) was nowhere to be seen. 1927 was the year of their 
big Beethoven Centennial series.

dl

On 8/30/2012 11:31 PM, DAVID BURNHAM wrote:
> I realize that a definitive answer to this question may be lost in time, but a friend and I were discussing the 1927 Columbia recording of the "Eroica" by Dr. Max von Shillings.  This recording was only released in the U.S.A. and Canada on Columbia;  the rest of the world got it on Odeon.  What perturbs us is why would Columbia release this Eroica only a year after the Henry Wood recording of 1926, which, I believe, is a far better recording technically.  The Shillings is so bereft of bass that when I first put it on I thought it was an acoustic recording, however it is a very exciting performance.
>
> Hopefully someone may have seen the paperwork associated with the Shillings recording and know the answer - or, at least have an intelligent guess.
>
> db
> _____________