[78-L] Pop Music thgru 1955(ish)

[jack palmer]

Bill,
    I tend to agree with you.  Of course I was in my 30s in the 50s so that probably affected my taste, but I wasn't as turned off by the music of the 50s as Steve Barr seems to have been.    Jack




________________________________
From: Bill Knowlton <udmacon1 at hotmail.com>
To: 78-L (2) <78-l at klickitat.78online.com>
Sent: Wed, January 13, 2010 1:38:33 PM
Subject: [78-L] Pop Music thgru 1955(ish)


Mr Barr sayeth: "



That assumes, then, that you actually LIKED hits like "This Old House," "Oh  Mein Papa" and
the rest of the (dubiously) "music" that was what one HAD to hear on radio in that era! I grew
up with that...I didn't like it then, and I doubt if I would even these days."



Well that's perfectly fine, Steve. One's taste in music is similar to taste in tooth paste.  You can't argue about it.



It would be nice if you put the ole "IMHO" in your post; just because you don't like the music of the early 'fifties doesn't make it dogma that it's no good..



I turned 12 in 1950 and loved "This Old House" (Stuart Hamblin who also wrote "It Is No Secret")...maybe not Oh My Papa...but YES, I LOVED Tennessee Waltz.



IMHO (note) it was a fun era. And the songs (IMHO again) by Frankie Lane, Joanie James, Rosemary Clooney, Eddie Fisher (sans "Papa"), Kay Starr, and Guy Mitchell appealed to me quite strongly.



Then I discovered that Hey Joe, Jambalaya, Cold Cold Heart, and others were pop covers of COUNTRY songs.



That made me an immediate convert to Country Music (until--IMHO--it went down the tubes starting with Young Love and Gone.)..



Sh-Boom????? Is that really better than Doggie In the Window? 



Have you ever heard the hilarious excerpt of the Jack Benny Show when his Sportsman Quartet sang it? Jack's reaction was --IMHO-- perfectly hilarious and dead-on accurate.



Tennessee Waltz was made a State Song. What State has given that honor to ShBoom?



All in fun....


BILL KNOWLTON, "Bluegrass Ramble," Sundays: 9 pm to midnight (EST) over WCNY-FM (91.3) Syracuse, WUNY (89.5) Utica, WJNY (90.9) Watertown NY, also: www.wcny.org udmacon1 at hotmail.com  Since 1973!
PO Box 2400, Syracuse NY 13220-2400. 315-457-6100
**********************************************************************
Join us Sunday night, Jan. 17th for the 37th Bluegrass Ramble Birthday Party with Lake Effect, The Salt Potatoes and the Delaney Brothers! We recorded it Jan 10th before an enthusiastic studio audience. A Radio Barn Dance as it used to be!!












EMAILING FOR THE GREATER GOOD
Join me                         
_______________________________________________
78-L mailing list
78-L at klickitat.78online.com
http://klickitat.78online.com/mailman/listinfo/78-l