[78-L] Another new history of jazz

[Jeff Sultanof]

You know, this really angers me. The jazz novice is not about to spend
$100.00 and plow through a lot of heavy-duty analysis. This kind of approach
turns people off to jazz. W.W. Norton ought to know better.

Don't get me started on Gary Giddins.

Jeff Sultanof

On Sun, Nov 22, 2009 at 9:39 PM, Taylor Bowie <bowiebks at isomedia.com> wrote:

> Lucky for me....Godot finally showed up!
>
> Taylor
>
>
>
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: "David Lennick" <dlennick at sympatico.ca>
> To: "78-L Mail List" <78-l at klickitat.78online.com>
> Sent: Sunday, November 22, 2009 6:02 PM
> Subject: Re: [78-L] Another new history of jazz
>
>
> I'm still waiting for Parts 3 & 4 of Stan Freberg's United States of
> America.
>
> And another issue of 78 Quarterly.
>
> And the Electrician or someone like him.
>
> dl
>
> fnarf at comcast.net wrote:
> > Is Giddins ever going to finish the second volume of his Bing Crosby bio?
> >
> >
> >
> > ----- Original Message -----
> > From: "Cary Ginell" <soundthink at live.com>
> > To: 78-l at klickitat.78online.com
> > Sent: Sunday, November 22, 2009 1:07:34 PM GMT -08:00 US/Canada Pacific
> > Subject: [78-L] Another new history of jazz
> >
> >
> > A new take on a standard
> >
> > This history of jazz is more a primer on how to listen to it
> >
> > By Steve Greenlee, Globe Staff  |  November 22, 2009
> >
> > Do we need another gargantuan book that purports to retell the history of
> > jazz? The aficionado’s bookcase is crammed with such texts, which come
> > and quickly go. But the latest one, by the highly respected and talented
> > jazz scribes Gary Giddins and Scott DeVeaux, arrives with a twist.
> >
> > Simply and audaciously titled “Jazz’’ this 704-page monster is
> > really more of a beginner’s guide. The well-informed won’t glean much
> > from these pages. But the listener who has only dipped his toes in and
> > would like to take a few swimming lessons - well, then, this is his book.
> >
> > At its heart, “Jazz’’ is a history lesson. Giddins and DeVeaux
> start
> > with post-Civil War African-American folk culture and wind up in 2008,
> > when the Grammy for best album went to Herbie Hancock for “River: The
> > Joni Letters,’’ his tribute to Joni Mitchell. But this book also
> > serves as a covert primer on how to hear jazz - what to listen for, and
> > how to understand what is going on. Such a conceit might seem
> > pretentious - indeed, it might seem arrogant, suggesting that the
> listener
> > needs to know something before she can appreciate the music and determine
> > whether she likes it - but it is not.
> >
> > If anything, the authors analyze individual performances to the extreme,
> > in their attempt to impart wisdom. Here is what distinguishes
> > “Jazz’’ from those that have come before: It contains copious
> > dissections of 78 tracks. A recording of Jelly Roll Morton’s “Dead
> Man
> > Blues’’ or Sarah Vaughan’s “Baby, Won’t You Please Come
> > Home?’’ is scrutinized and annotated, with authors’ notes
> explaining
> > what happens as the tune begins, eight seconds into it, and on and on.
> >
> > In just about every case, it’s an overly academic exercise that becomes
> > a buzzkill. By nature, a jazz fan wants to be surprised, energized, even
> > jolted by music. Forget all that. A two-and-half-minute recording of
> > “Weather Bird’’ by Louis Armstrong and Earl Hines consumes two
> pages
> > of examination: “0:00: Armstrong plays the opening melody on trumpet,
> > discreetly backed by Hines’s piano. 0:04 Armstrong displays his command
> > of dynamics. Some notes are played at full volume.’’ Et cetera, et
> > cetera.
> >
> > In many instances the intense analysis comes at the expense of history.
> > Billie Holiday was perhaps jazz’s most important singer, yet the
> > authors’ dissection of “A Sailboat in the Moonlight,’’ one of her
> > lesser known pieces, gets as much ink as does her entire career. More
> > problematic is that the passages mean nothing to the reader unless the
> > reader is multitasking: reading and listening to a recording at the same
> > time. Yet who among us possesses all of the recordings mentioned herein?
> >
> > Ah, problem solved. And here’s the twist: It’s not just a book;
> it’s
> > a CD box set. W.W. Norton & Co. is simultaneously releasing a four-CD
> > package containing all 78 tracks. This is ingenious marketing: $40 book +
> > $60 CD set = $100 sale. But, again, this book (and CD collection) is for
> > the novice, and it would be hard to improve upon “Recordings: For
> > Jazz’’ as an audio introduction. The selections do a fine job of
> > representing the genre’s many stages, and the audio fidelity is
> supreme.
> >
> > Get beyond all that, though, and there’s not much to distinguish the
> > actual book, which is largely an aggregation of what has come before.
> > Complex life stories - Django Reinhardt’s, Thelonious Monk’s, Ella
> > Fitzgerald’s - are condensed in a few paragraphs. Landmark recordings
> > are dispensed with no sooner than they are introduced. Yes, the authors
> > are trying to distill 100 years of history but still: We’ve heard all
> > this before. The lack of footnoting is particularly troubling. The
> > so-called end notes are insufficient; they fail to attribute even the
> most
> > basic sourcing. Then there are the liberties taken by Giddins and
> DeVeaux.
> > They write that free-jazz saxophonist Albert Ayler “died, a suicide, at
> > thirty-four.’’ Really? Ayler’s death has been a constant source of
> > speculation and argument. His body was found floating in New York’s
> East
> > River in 1970, and the cause of death was never determined.
> >
> > Quibbles aside, one could do much worse for an introduction to jazz.
> > It’s all here (albeit abbreviated), from Bessie Smith to Buddy Bolden
> to
> > Louis Armstrong to Coleman Hawkins to Charlie Parker to John Coltrane to
> > Jason Moran. The basic configurations of the jazz ensemble are examined
> > and explained for the uninitiated. Frank Sinatra, for once, gets respect
> > in a jazz history, and fusion - the real thing, as done by Miles Davis
> and
> > his compatriots - gets more due than Ken Burns and his ilk would ever
> > afford. George Russell’s complicated theories about chords’ relation
> > to one another are explained in a way almost anyone can comprehend, and
> > the contributions of contemporaries as disparate as Wynton Marsalis and
> > Vijay Iyer are presented in their proper contexts. Massachusetts finally
> > gets its props as the center of jazz education, and Boston-bred George
> > Wein, the impresario behind the Newport Jazz Festival, gets more than the
> > requisite passing mention.
> >
> > All of which is well and good. Just be prepared to buy the CDs if you
> want
> > to appreciate “Jazz’’ to its fullest.
> >
> > Steve Greenlee can be reached at greenlee at globe.com.
> > _________________________________________________________
> _______________________________________________
> 78-L mailing list
> 78-L at klickitat.78online.com
> http://klickitat.78online.com/mailman/listinfo/78-l
>
> _______________________________________________
> 78-L mailing list
> 78-L at klickitat.78online.com
> http://klickitat.78online.com/mailman/listinfo/78-l
>