[78-L] Goodman/Shaw, was Re: no-no

Howard Friedman hsf318 at comcast.net
Wed Oct 22 21:02:24 PDT 2008


I believe anyone who ever played the clarinet will agree Shaw's
"Concerto" is a pastiche of trivial, flashy, and easy to play figures
designed for audiences impressed by superficial display.

And Goodman could out swing Shaw anytime.

Doug

Goodman had the timbre of the classical clarinet, Shaw had a much warmer tone.  Maybe that's why I prefer him.

Howard




More information about the 78-L mailing list